Manchester United turned to Mauricio Pochettino because, ultimately, appointing a manager capable of bringing the best out of people was the last option left to try at Old Trafford

The only type of manager the Red Devils had yet to try was one who could develop players and get the best out of them through personal relationships.
by Redazione Undici 13 November 2026 at 15:10

Manchester United are trying everything to stop a decline that looks increasingly difficult to reverse. Michael Carrick has gone too – perhaps an unavoidable decision when a club of United’s stature finds itself in the relegation zone (!) – adding another hefty payout to the growing list of managerial casualties. One after another, the men handed Sir Alex Ferguson’s old job have come and gone, most of them failing, some more spectacularly than others. Ferguson’s legacy has almost become a curse. Apart from the occasional flash of defiance, most notably Mourinho’s Europa League triumph, way back in 2017, England’s most decorated club has spent years sinking into a nightmare. At times, outright farce. Losing a European final to Tottenham was a humiliation no one else had managed before. Finishing third in the Premier League just a few months ago, only to find themselves at the bottom today, gives some idea of the scale of the crisis. So does the mood among supporters, increasingly worn down by the constant swings between hope and humiliation. And so, perhaps out of desperation, perhaps for want of a better option, United have decided to start again with Mauricio Pochettino.

He is a very different proposition from any of the managers who have come before him. Look back at the post-Ferguson years. David Moyes, the first to take over, was never remotely in Sir Alex’s league. Mourinho perhaps was, in certain respects, but even the Special One, with all his emotional force, eventually struggled to make himself at home in the peculiar world of Old Trafford. Then came the succession of appointments: homegrown gambles such as Solskjaer and Carrick, alongside high-profile imports like Van Gaal, Ten Hag and Amorim. One dismissal after another. Which leaves one kind of manager United have yet to try: someone who builds players, invests in relationships over time and doesn’t believe winning is the only measure of a good manager. A distinction that may have escaped a hierarchy seemingly incapable of going very long without a trophy.

Pochettino has built his career around precisely that idea. His five years at Tottenham were perhaps its clearest expression, culminating in a historic Champions League final. Spurs, of course, are not Manchester United, whether in stature, ambition or resources. At the biggest clubs, things have been less straightforward. He lasted a single season at PSG, another at Chelsea, without leaving much of a mark at either, particularly when it came to the kind of long-term project he has always believed in. Two years ago, he took charge of the United States national team, where he began to lay the foundations for the next step in American football. The home World Cup, despite the early excitement, ended in disappointment, the Americans knocked out by Belgium in brutal fashion. His work with younger players, though, was a different story. The generational renewal of the squad gave him the chance to build something over time, becoming a father figure to a group of young players looking for someone to guide them.

Now, all that has been turned on its head by the call from Manchester United. Pochettino has agreed a severance deal with the US Soccer Federation and is preparing to take over from Carrick. He will inherit a club in ruins and a dressing room full of lost prima donnas. Not exactly an easy place to start. Then again, there is one thing in his favour: for a club like Manchester United, it is hard to imagine things getting much worse. That is the bet he is making, knowing full well that nobody before him has managed to turn things around. Good luck. He’ll need it.

>

Read also