Michael Carrick is the eighth Manchester United manager to receive a severance payment after being sacked. He joins a now lengthy list of men handed the task of succeeding Sir Alex Ferguson, who retired in 2013, only to lose their jobs along the way. Before Carrick came David Moyes, Louis van Gaal, José Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Erik ten Hag, Ralf Rangnick and Ruben Amorim. It is hard to escape the conclusion that United’s problems run rather deeper than the manager’s office. But there is another measure of the club’s disastrous ownership and executive management: the money spent hiring and then getting rid of all these men. According to the Telegraph, the bill is expected to reach €120 million, once Carrick’s compensation and the cost of appointing a successor are included. A remarkable sum, particularly given what United have had to show for it.
Here is how it breaks down. David Moyes, Ferguson’s hand-picked successor, arrived at Old Trafford in 2013 on a six-year contract. He lasted just ten months. His dismissal cost the club €5.8 million, with a further €3 million or so spent terminating the contracts of staff members Moyes had chosen not to retain. Next came Van Gaal, whose two years at Old Trafford cost €10 million. He was replaced by Mourinho, who delivered the Europa League and League Cup in 2017 before being sacked at the end of 2018. The combined cost of his appointment and dismissal was €24 million.
The bill for hiring and firing Solskjaer, between 2018 and 2021, came to €11 million. Rangnick’s six months at Old Trafford cost €17.5 million. He had arrived as interim manager, with the prospect of moving into a consultancy role, but walked away from the entire arrangement at the end of the 2021/22 season. Ten Hag’s dismissal cost another €12.5 million. Then came Amorim, whose appointment and eventual departure took a further €20 million out of the club. And now Carrick: sending him and his staff on their way will cost at least €6 million.
That still leaves a few million to account for before the total reaches €120 million. The Telegraph expects the gap to be made up by the cost of a possible move for Mauricio Pochettino. Having renewed his contract as United States head coach after the World Cup, he would come with a release clause worth €9 million. There is a further detail worth bearing in mind: none of these figures includes the salaries paid to the managers or their staff. Nor do they include the fees and compensation involved in hiring and dismissing the sporting directors charged with overseeing United’s reconstruction – another job that once fell to Ferguson. Dan Ashworth, for instance, was lured away from Newcastle for €2.5 million. Five months later, United sacked him, paying out a severance package worth more than €5 million. Two more figures, from elsewhere in the club’s accounts, complete the picture. An internal restructuring over the past two years has resulted in 322 job cuts. Across the last seven financial years, United have recorded losses of €530 million. Some rebuild.